A Costume for Charly

August 22, 2022
Young Charly, portrayed with brown skin, can’t decide whether to be “fabulous or frightening” for Halloween, but
they know one thing for sure: this year’s costume has to be “something that showed they were both a boy and a girl.” Barajas’s slick, animation-like illustrations have a slice-of-life energy as they envision Charly assessing the options in the costume box: a Red Riding Hood outfit makes Charly’s “boy half felt eaten by the wolf,” while a Dracula costume “took a bite out of their girl half.” Momentarily disheartened (“Why can’t there be a costume just for me?”), Charly musters some ingenuity worthy of Project Runway. In Malone’s earnest prose, there is never any doubt in this protagonist, who does whatever it takes to feel “one hundred percent Charly.” An afterword discusses bigender identity. Ages 4–12.

July 8, 2022

PreS-Gr 2-Bi-gender Charly is determined to find a Halloween costume that represents their whole identity, showing they're both a boy and a girl. Their Dracula costume makes their femme side feel erased, and the Little Red Riding Hood costume leaves their masc side in the dust. The only solution? Charly must get creative! They put their snipping and sewing skills to work and create a costume that makes them feel "joyfully jazzed, harmoniously hopeful, and one hundred percent Charly." Cartoon-style digital illustrations are tinged with blue and purple Halloween hues and feature some whimsical, magical flourishes. When the time comes for the big reveal, Charly's mostly accepting friends think their costume is wacky but wonderful. Charly's refreshing confidence in their own gender identity is evident throughout the story, though the implication that a Dracula costume might only be for boys because Dracula was a male vampire may strike some readers as unnecessarily binary. Back matter includes information on bi-gender identity and select LGBTQIA+ resources. VERDICT Charly's joyous creativity and persistence will encourage trick-or-readers to think outside of the box this Halloween. -Allison Staley

Copyright 2022 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

September 1, 2022
"Charly rummaged through the mishmash in the old costumes box for something that showed they were both a girl and a boy." (An appended note identifies Charly as bigender.) The Red Riding Hood costume they find feels too feminine; the Dracula one, too masculine -- neither expresses wholly who they are. Then Charly has an idea: to create "one [costume] from two." And on Halloween night, out trick-or-treating with friends, they feel "one hundred percent Charly." Cartoony illustrations capture Charly's determination to find the right costume, and the way wearing it ultimately makes them feel "joyfully jazzed" and "harmoniously hopeful." Martha V. Parravano

(Copyright 2022 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

July 1, 2022
"Charly rummaged through the mishmash in the old costumes box for something that showed they were both a girl and a boy." (An appended note identifies Charly as bigender.) The Red Riding Hood costume they find feels too feminine; the Dracula one, too masculine -- neither expresses wholly who they are. Then Charly has an idea: to create "one �costume] from two." And on Halloween night, out trick-or-treating with friends, they feel "one hundred percent Charly." Cartoony illustrations capture Charly's determination to find the right costume, and the way wearing it ultimately makes them feel "joyfully jazzed" and "harmoniously hopeful."

(Copyright 2022 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)